May 19, 2015
Tax Policy Update
NUMBER OF THE WEEK: 40 percent.
The average combined federal and state tax rate paid by most U.S.-based firms, according to a Wall Street Journal op-ed by James Freeman today, entitled
“The Tax Takeover Craze.” Freeman claims this is “roughly double the average
in Europe and Asia,” and is the driving force behind the continuing trend of companies moving their headquarters overseas. Grain of salt: the
conservative-leaning Tax Foundation has warned against using the “average effective tax rate” as a reliable measure, noting that it “is irregular
from year to year due to the complexity and instability of the corporate tax code.” A better measure,
according to the Tax Foundation, is the marginal effective tax
rate (METR) which averages around 35 percent—still higher than in any other developed country.
Senate Finance Tax Reform Working Group Spotlight: Individual Income Tax
TAX TALK: PRESIDENTIAL
Transportation Funding: A (Structurally Deficient) Bridge Too Far.
With the May 31 deadline just around the corner, lawmakers have little choice but to coalesce around a two-month extension of highway funding
authorization—setting the stage for a summer of tough negotiations. The two-month patch, the Highway Transportation Funding Act of 2015 (H.R. 2353), introduced by Congressmen Bill Shuster (R-PA) and Paul Ryan (R-WI), will be up for debate
on the House floor on Tuesday. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) has lined up a similar measure, introduced by Senators Tom Carper
(D-DE) and Barbara Boxer (D-CA), in the upper chamber.
Democrats and Republicans are pointing fingers at one another for failing to negotiate a longer extension that would carry surface transportation projects
at least through the end of the year—with an $11 billion price tag. Republicans were reportedly ready to fork over $5.5 billion in revenue offsets from
changes to a mish-mash of relatively obscure tax policies but only if Democrats could come up with the other half through spending cuts. Bottom
line—securing a six-year reauthorization bill before the two-month patch expires at the end of July will be an uphill climb.
Meanwhile, House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-CA)
told reporters yesterday he “see[s] a path”
for a long-term highway funding bill paid for by tax reform before the end of this year, and House Ways and Means Chairman Paul Ryan continues to hint at
efforts at international and corporate reforms this year as a “down payment” for more comprehensive reforms in the next Congress.
R&D Tax Credit Up for Debate.
The American Research and Competitiveness Act of 2015 (H.R. 880) is up for consideration in the House on Wednesday. Approved by the Ways and Means
Committee in a highly-partisan vote, the legislation aims to simplify and make permanent the Research and Development Tax Credit. Under the proposal
introduced by Rep. Kevin Brady (R-TX), the basic research and energy research credits would be made permanent – the base period for the basic research
credit would be changed to a three-year rolling average. The alternative simplified method (ASC) for calculating the credit would also be made permanent
with the increased rate of 20 percent. Small businesses would be allowed to claim the credit to offset the alternative minimum tax. Click
here to read the full text of the bill.
Ways & Means Sets Sight on Medical Device Tax Repeal.
The House Ways and Means Committee is expected to mark up a bill that would repeal the medical device tax. The Protect Medical Innovation Act of 2015 (H.R. 160) would cost approximately $29 billion over 10 years – an offset for the loss of revenue has not yet
been identified, however. The bill introduced by Rep. Erik Paulsen (R-MN) back in January has garnered substantial support among his Republican colleagues.
A similar measure (S. 844) has also been introduced in the Senate by Senator Ed Markey (D-MA) who is looking to eliminate certain tax breaks for oil
companies to help pay for the repeal. A repeal of the 2.3 percent medical device tax also enjoys strong support from the Senate Finance Chairman Orrin
Senate Finance Tax Reform Working Group Spotlight: Individual Income Tax
With the focus of tax reform gradually shifting towards a business-only overhaul, members of the Senate Finance Individual Income Tax Working Group have
more or less resigned themselves to offering more modest recommendations for reform. Instead of cutting the 39.6 percent top rate, the working group has
turned its attention to provisions with potential bipartisan support, such as those related to education, charitable giving, and tax administration. In the
spotlight this week is the comment letter submitted by the Charitable Giving Coalition, which seeks to preserve the full scope and value of the charitable
Members of the Senate Finance Committee’s Individual Income Tax Working Group
Chuck Grassley, IA (co-chair)
Mike Enzi, WY (co-chair)
Mike Crapo, ID
John Cornyn, TX
Pat Toomey, PA
Debbie Stabenow, MI (co-chair)
Charles Schumer, NY
Bill Nelson, FL
Robert Menendez, NJ
Michael Bennet, CO
Comment Spotlight: Charitable Giving Coalition
In its submission, the Charitable Giving Coalition (“Coalition”) urged the Senate Finance Committee to preserve the full scope and value of the charitable deduction provision. The Coalition members include, among others, the American Red Cross, Salvation Army, and the United Way Worldwide. The Coalition expressed its concern that proposed changes to the provision based on the president’s cap of 28 percent for certain taxpayer would result in a loss of $9.4 billion in the first year. The full submission can be found
here. This week, the Senate Finance working group on individual income has found progress in streamlining education credits and the benefits of charitable contributions.
TAX TALK: PRESIDENTIAL AMBITIONS
Although New Jersey Governor Chris Christie has not officially declared his candidacy, the GOP presidential hopeful has unveiled a tax plan that calls for
rate cuts and simplification of the U.S. tax code. Under the proposal, the corporate tax would be slashed to 25 percent from the current 35 percent rate.
Christie would also reduce the number of individual income tax brackets to three, where the top rate should not exceed 28 percent. The governor’s plan also
seeks to be revenue-neutral by eliminating or modifying “enough deductions, credits and targeted provisions in the code – both on the personal and the
corporate sides.” Christie would keep the deductions for charitable giving but would limit the home mortgage interest deduction to the purchase of one’s
first home. Read more
German Finance Minister Signals FTT Not Ready for 2016.
Following a meeting in Brussels amongst EU finance ministers, German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble indicated that the much vaunted financial
transaction tax would not be ready to be introduced next year. Earlier this year, the 11 EU states involved had reached an agreement that it would tax the
widest possible base at a low rate, and that implementation in 2016 was viable. However, Austrian Finance Minister Schelling indicated that there continues
to be some disagreement as some of the states were trying to exclude interest-rate derivatives. Schaeuble noted that there some points of progress,
particularly in the area of where the tax would be levied. The tax would be imposed on equities where the trade occurred, and derivatives where the
security was issued.
FATCA Self-Certification Issue Raising Concerns Across Jurisdictions.
Many practitioners are focusing their attention on the discrepancy in the self-certification requirement under the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act. Last
month, we had reported that a Treasury official cleared up any confusion that under FATCA, self-certification is a requisite to opening accounts and
maintaining existing accounts in jurisdictions that have Model 1 intergovernmental agreements in place. The intergovernmental agreements with United
Kingdom and Canada do not provide that self-certification is required, rather so long as the accounts are reportable, they can be opened. With FATCA
deadlines soon approaching, certain foreign financial institutions are left in a quandary as to whether they will be subjected to the 30% withholding
requirement under FATCA.
OECD Release Discussion Draft on PE Status.
On May 15, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development released its revised discussion draft on Action 7 (Prevent the Artificial Avoidance on
PE Status) of the Base Erosion and Profit Shifting project. The recent draft takes into account the comments received from its prior draft, and proposes to
rewrite the rules on permanent establishment based on these comments. Of four options offered in rewriting the rules, the draft opts for the second option,
which some practitioners view as lowering the permanent establishment threshold but allowing for more subjectivity. The draft is available
here and comments are due by
June 12, 2015.
House Small Business Committee
The Economic Growth, Tax and Capital Access Subcommittee holds a hearing on “Improving Capital Access Programs within the SBA.”
House Judiciary Committee
The Regulatory Reform Subcommittee holds a
"Ongoing Oversight: Monitoring the Activities of the Justice Department's Civil, Tax and Environment and Natural Resources Divisions and the U.S. Trustee
Bloomberg holds a webinar to discuss the revised BEPS discussion draft on preventing the artificial avoidance of permanent establishment status (Action 7).